91 blog reactions to http://commentisfree.guardian.co.uk/mike_marqusee/2008/03/israels_jewish_critics.html

censors meanwhile eliminate as many as one in ten posts, which they consider to be unsavoury. So should we infer that the following posts, which can still be read on Comment Is Free, are endorsed by The Guardian: In an article on the site in March, Guardian readers railed against Israel...

censors meanwhile eliminate as many as one in ten posts, which they consider to be unsavoury. So should we infer that the following posts, which can still be read on Comment Is Free, are endorsed by The Guardian: In an article on the site in March, Guardian readers railed against Israel and "Zionists", their codeword for 'bad Jews'. Of nearly 500 comments posted on the article, almost 10 per cent were edited or deleted by Guardian moderators but that still left room for readers to complain that "no Jew can do any wrong", accuse the US

censors meanwhile eliminate as many as one in ten posts, which they consider to be unsavoury. So should we infer that the following posts, which can still be read on Comment Is Free, are endorsed by The Guardian: In an article on the site in March, Guardian readers railed against Israel and "Zionists", their codeword for 'bad Jews'. Of nearly 500 comments posted on the article, almost 10 per cent were edited or deleted by Guardian moderators but that still left room for readers to complain that "no Jew can do any wrong", accuse the US

censors meanwhile eliminate as many as one in ten posts, which they consider to be unsavoury. So should we infer that the following posts, which can still be read on Comment Is Free, are endorsed by The Guardian: In an article on the site in March, Guardian readers railed against Israel and "Zionists", their codeword for 'bad Jews'. Of nearly 500 comments posted on the article, almost 10 per cent were edited or deleted by Guardian moderators but that still left room for readers to complain that "no Jew can do any wrong", accuse the US

an author who has written about everything from boxer Mohammed Ali to the counter culture in the sixties. The link is an excerpt from his most recent book, which is an autobiography. An edited version was posted on the CIF website and generated huge debate. I find these issues extremely interesting because it makes us realise how strong the drive to silence critics inside Israel is, and how we should therefore be very supportive to those who sacrifice their own reputations, careers and lives for the

demeurés lamentablement impunis. Il faut avoir le courage de le dénoncer, pas de s'écraser devant l'intimidation. Je vous invite d'ailleurs à lire l'excellent commentaire du columnist Mike Marqusee, du journal The Guardian, en cliquant ici. Stéphane Gendron Chaque jour à Gaza ou ailleurs en Palestine, des parents enterrent leurs enfants.

demeurés lamentablement impunis. Il faut avoir le courage de le dénoncer, pas de s'écraser devant l'intimidation. Je vous invite d'ailleurs à lire l'excellent commentaire du columnist Mike Marqusee, du journal The Guardian, en cliquant ici. Stéphane Gendron Chaque jour à Gaza ou ailleurs en Palestine, des parents enterrent leurs enfants.

Idag har Maqusee blivit attackerad föera gånger, men också vant sig vid uttrycket. Som om enda orsaken till att vara anti-sionist skulle vara någon sorts mentalsjukdom, en neutorisk åkomma. Själv säger han: "Anti-sionismen bygger på vägran att acceptera diskriminering på rasmässig eller religiös grund. Judarna i Israel har varje rätt att leva säkert, att följa sin religion och att ta hänsyn (eller ej) till sin kulturella bakgrund, att tala

An extract from If I Am Not for Myself appeared in The Guardian on 4 March. A further brief extract was published on Comment is free, the Guardian website, and is followed by a very large number of readers’ comments.

Guardian: Mike Marqusee. Anti-Zionism is part of a larger opposition to racism, an expression of solidarity with the Palestinians as victims of injustice… As long as there has been Zionism, there have been anti-Zionist